Losing consistently in a trend is frustrating. It tends to make people feel either stupid or conspired against. The market always goes up ... until you buy. What's with that?submitted by whatthefx to Forex [link] [comments]
If you find yourself getting the run around in trending moves, this post should help.
We'll start with having a look at the areas common styles of trend following can generate losing signals '/ stop losses. The two main types of trend trading are breakouts and retracements. Here we can see the areas they are likely to generate losing trades in a typical trend formation.
On the left, we have breakout loses. On the right we have retracement losses.
The trades on the right are not too much of a problem. If you had a sold trend trading strategy using breakouts and maintained it with good money management, you'd be doing well. Having some strings of small losses would not matter relative to the trend moves you catch. It's this red bit. This is where things get sketchy. Here a lot of false signals will be generated. In a larger picture for retracement traders, but also on short term false breakouts.
Strategies that would have been very profitable ran through the blue area can become breakeven or losing strategies in the red area. This is actually (in my view) likely the reason most trend based EAs that can be designed easily or bought have limited long term profitability even if they produce great short term results. To make money in a blue market, the EA needs you to tell it how to do two things. Not get stopped out, and sell. There may be bumpy bits, but it will make money so long as that market condition continues.
This is all well and good, but the reality of having to deal with risk control in adverse market conditions will inevitably come along. When this happens, not adapting your trend strategy to filter out the losing streaks that most strategies will generate seriously hampers your net profitability and can even turn a good strategy bad.
In the early week gap and brief breakout on USDJPY, I thought it was likely we were switching from a blue market to a red market. So I activated the trend followers of different variations on my Shorting Noobs strategy, and waited to see if they'd pick up the worst signals (giving me ideal entries).
I explained what I thought the best trade pan for the sort of price action we'd see in the coming trading sessions would be.
My theory here is if you put a bunch of okay strategies (and these are not horrible traders. They have rules, and follow them. Do overall okay) into the very worst conditions, they'll do the worst thing. Which saves me the effort of being here doing what I think is the best thing. To look for big drops, and then it have a little false breakout. Buy this and take profits into spikes.
Here that is a bit closer.
Particularly where the red mark is, this has produce a perfect counter signal. Sharp drop, false breakout. Buy and take profit into spike up.
The interesting thing about this for me, is I do not find too much to be critical about with many of these positions if we are to look at the market from the perspective of a seller. Their stop losses seem to make sense from much of the stop loss rules commonly used (and ones working for them okay in other times of the strategy), but they're commonly being stopped out at the highs.
The main problem most strategies have is the recurrence of what can be increasingly strong looking sell signals. When using solid rules, this is a limited problem (can still be big), but without this and with there being emotional decisions made, this is a really hard time to trade. It's easy to lose all your money trying to follow the trend here, without really doing too much wrong other than starting to chase a loss or refuse to accept a loss. Then things happen so quickly, and that's it. Being a revenge seller selling into the bear engulfing bars right before the 50 pips 1 minute candles does not go well a few times in a row (tried and tested, would not recommend).
As I mentioned in the comments for the OP of this analysis, I stopped selling at 106.05. I stopped copying most of the strategies there because I didn't want them accumulating sells at a possible high. All through the consolidation period their have been sells accumulating and obviously the stops are above the highs, which is exactly the area I'd expect to spike out and reverse from in this pattern. It's what my manual trade plan inverts.
So at this point these strategies that have been doing well over the blue period (which has been a longer time) have lost most of gains. If the trend continues from here in the main they will breakeven on this red section (would be okay). If there are spike outs of the highs they will generate a lot more losing signals. By the end of this, strategies that have been profitable for 3 months will have leaked back a substantial amount of that in only 4 - 5 days.
Learning to remove these correction weeks from their trading patterns would very much benefit most trend following systems.
Here's the overall results from betting against either trend following or trend reversal mistakes like this.
The EA places buy stoploss few pips below red line (Tokyo session lowest price) and sell stoploss few pips above green line (Tokyo session highest price) UsePartialClose – user has an option to partially close profitable trades; UseEoDClose – if TRUE, the EA closes any open trade at the end of the day (at 23:55) The EA places buy stop-loss few pips below the red line (Tokyo session lowest price) and sell stop loss few pips above the green line (Tokyo session highest price) UsePartialClose – the user has an option to partially close profitable trades; UseEoDClose – if TRUE, the EA closes any open trade at the end of the day (at 23:55) The three key Show Trade Info – if TRUE, this is a visual display on the top right corner of the chart with key trade information e.g. lot sizes, account balance, equity, drawdown, number of trades, profit, risk percent, etc.; ShowComment – if TRUE, this displays comments on the chart showing the status of the three rules, GMT time, breakout candles, etc; Show PrintOut – if TRUE, this prints out and Breakout Alert Indicator for MT4 by Forex Strategies Revealed . The expert advisor listed below is a premium EA, but it does offer more options and customization for those wanting a little more. Make sure to take into account the trading session you are using your breakout strategy and the time frame you are trading it on. Forex breakout EA: A breakout method can supplement other trading patterns and offer diversification.Big breakouts are “occasion driven” in that they regularly show up around the release of critical facts. Minor breakouts, candle breakout ea which can be more frequent, often have a “technical pull” behind them.
[index]          
London Breakout Trading Session Live 11-13-19 - Duration: 11:41. LuisTutorialTV 168 views. ... How To Start Forex Trading With $100 2 Ways To Manage Your Account - Duration: 4:57. 3 simple steps to make profit by Tokyo Box Breakout Strategy. I am showing the break out strategy with LIVE trading on CHFJPY on 26 of June, 2019, and explaining why it works on what currency pair. How to Trade the US Session in Forex.. How to Trade with Market Makers - Duration: 21:41. ... New York Session Daily Breakout Trading Strategy - Duration: 16:00. SlickTrade 870 views. The ERXGen (Early Riser Next Generation) Breakout System is a short-term trading technique built around the phenomenon that there are certain times of the trading day when price volatility has the ... Latest version of our Smart Auto BreakOut EA. It comes with completely new user interface which allows users to control trading process even more easily with just single button clicks.